Milk and Cream Bar Jersey City is officially open. The New York-based ice cream shop is located at 175 Newark Avenue. (They’re sandwiched in between Sweetberry Bowls and K9dergarten).
The ice cream shop blends popular breakfast cereals with various ice cream flavors to create delicious treats like its signature Cookie Crisp Carnival (pictured) — a mix of Cookie Crisp cereal, Oreos, and cookie dough ice cream. There’s also the Apple Jack Avalanche, a tasty blend of Apple Jacks, Cinnamon Toast Crunch, and Granola Crisp with a swirl of caramel drizzle.
- Now open: Emma’s JSQ
- Jersey City reopening: What you need to know
Adventurous foodies can also create their own cereal-ice-cream combos. Milk and Cream Bar lets you choose from Trix, Honey Bunches of Oats, Apple Jacks, Cocoa Puffs, and more. In total, there are over 15 different cereals to choose from. Just pick your cereal, choose an ice cream flavor, and then finish it off with either fruit or cereal/candy toppings. (Toppings include Frosted Flakes, M&M’s, or Reese’s Pieces).
Milk and Cream originally opened in New York at 159 Mott Street. The ice cream parlor offers seasonal flavors and collabs with other dessert shops. Their Cocoa Matcha Swirl, for instance, (pictured above) is a collab with New York’s Spot Dessert Bar. During Halloween, the shop offers its Franken-Berry and Boo-Berry flavors. All New York collabs and flavors will be offered at Milk and Cream Jersey City.
In addition to ice cream, Milk and Cream also offers milkshakes and actual bowls of cereal. (If you recall, they were dishing out milkshakes at last year’s All About Downtown Street Fest). Currently, there are no pints available for purchase and customers can only order cups (no cones).
Friend and fellow foodie GirlEatsNYC introduced us to Milk and Cream Bar a few years ago. After trying their ice cream creations on a few occasions, we can say that their treats are as delicious as they look and sound.
Milk and Cream Bar Jersey City Menu
This is Milk and Cream’s first Jersey City shop and their first franchise. The shop will be closed Mondays and Tuesdays and open Wednesdays through Sundays from 1pm to 8pm. You can give Milk and Cream Jersey City a follow on their Insta for any new updates.
Since its opening on May 28, Milk and Cream Jersey City has experienced a massive surge in demand. Currently, there’s no online ordering so you may want to go off hours (on a weekday) to avoid having to wait in line.
Milk and Cream Jersey City — April 2022 Special
Through May 1, Milk and Cream Bar is donating $1 from every sale to Jersey City-based organization Whole Spectrum Autism to celebrate Autism acceptance month.
